LVP vs. Hardwood: Cost & Durability for Rhode Island Homes
Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) and hardwood flooring both offer warmth, character, and beauty that can transform any space, but they differ in cost, performance, and long-term value.
So, which one is right for your Rhode Island home?
This guide breaks down the key differences between LVP vs. hardwood, helping you make the right investment for your home. We’ll look at durability, style, comfort, maintenance, and resale value, while factoring in Rhode Island’s unique coastal climate.
Whether you’re renovating your forever home or preparing to sell, understanding these differences will help you choose the flooring that fits your lifestyle and budget best.
P.S. Need help with flooring services in Rhode Island? Give us a call at 401-884-8300 or book a free consultation online. The team at Bart’s Carpet Sales is here to help with all your flooring needs.
Comparing Engineered Hardwood vs. LVP Flooring
Before diving into the details, here’s a side-by-side comparison of engineered hardwood vs. LVP flooring, focusing on what really matters for everyday Rhode Island living.
| Feature | Hardwood Flooring | Luxury Vinyl Plank (LVP) |
|---|---|---|
| Durability | Long-lasting; can be refinished | Extremely durable; resistant to scratches and dents |
| Style | Authentic wood look and feel | Realistic visuals that mimic wood species |
| Comfort | Warm, natural underfoot | Softer and quieter, especially with underlayment |
| Maintenance | Requires regular care and refinishing | Low maintenance; easy to clean |
| Costs | Higher upfront investment | Lower installation and material costs |
| Best for | Long-term homeowners, high-end remodels | Busy families, rentals, coastal homes |
Now, let’s explore what these differences mean for real-world performance and value.
Durability and Performance in Everyday Life
When flooring is part of daily life, from sandy shoes after a trip to Narragansett Beach to pets running across the living room, durability matters more than ever.
Scratch and Water Resistance
If you have pets or kids, we suggest leaning toward LVP flooring vs. hardwood because of one major reason: water resistance.
LVP is 100% waterproof, making it ideal for basements, bathrooms, and kitchens where spills are inevitable. Even in coastal homes where humidity levels fluctuate, LVP won’t warp, swell, or cup.
By contrast, hardwood flooring (including engineered wood) can be sensitive to moisture. Engineered options perform better than solid hardwood since their layered construction resists some warping, but they’re still not suitable for areas with standing water.
If your home sits near the shoreline or you want something low-maintenance for a busy household, LVP clearly wins this round.
Lifespan and Wear Over Time
When properly installed and cared for, hardwood floors can last 50 years or more, sometimes even a lifetime. They can be sanded and refinished multiple times, allowing you to refresh their look as trends change.
LVP, on the other hand, can’t be refinished, but it’s built to withstand wear for 15–25 years, depending on the product’s thickness and wear layer. Many modern LVPs feature scratch- and dent-resistant coatings, meaning your floor looks newer for longer without the need for refinishing.
In Rhode Island’s fluctuating climate, hardwood may expand and contract slightly throughout the seasons, whereas LVP stays stable. For homeowners who want minimal upkeep and consistent performance, LVP flooring offers unbeatable convenience.
Style, Comfort, and Aesthetic Appeal
Rhode Island homes often blend coastal charm with timeless New England style. The good news is that both LVP and hardwood beautifully complement these interiors.
Look and Feel Underfoot
Hardwood flooring has a natural texture and warmth that’s hard to replicate. Walking barefoot across real oak or maple feels luxurious and grounding, especially on chilly winter mornings.
LVP, however, has come a long way. Modern versions use advanced imaging and embossing technologies that mirror the look and grain of real wood species like hickory, walnut, and even reclaimed oak. Many Rhode Island homeowners are surprised by how realistic high-end LVP feels underfoot, especially when paired with a quality underlayment.
Design Versatility
Both luxury vinyl plank and hardwood adapt beautifully to a variety of home styles from classic Cape Cod cottages to sleek modern condos.
Hardwood’s natural grain and stain options provide timeless sophistication, while engineered hardwood vs. LVP offers more design flexibility for moisture-prone spaces.
LVP comes in hundreds of finishes, plank widths, and textures — even extra-wide formats that make small rooms appear more spacious. Plus, it can mimic rare or exotic wood species without the high cost or maintenance.
LVP vs. Hardwood: Cost Comparison
When it comes to the cost of LVP vs hardwood, the difference can be significant — not just at purchase, but over time.
On average, Luxury vinyl flooring costs $3–$7 per square foot installed, depending on the brand and design. Meanwhile, hardwood flooring (including engineered wood) ranges from $8–$15 per square foot installed.
LVP is easier and faster to install, especially with click-lock planks that don’t require nails or glue. This reduces labor costs and makes it a popular choice for budget-conscious homeowners or large projects.
Hardwood installation takes longer and requires professional expertise, particularly for sanding and finishing.
Long-Term Value and Maintenance Costs
Hardwood floors may cost more upfront, but they’re often considered an investment. Their ability to be refinished gives them a longer life and a higher resale value.
LVP, on the other hand, has minimal maintenance costs — no waxing, sealing, or refinishing needed. A simple sweep and occasional mop keep it looking great. For homeowners who prioritize convenience and want to avoid ongoing upkeep, LVP flooring offers a low-stress alternative.
Rhode Island Pricing Insights
Local pricing can fluctuate based on factors like material sourcing, contractor availability, and the region’s coastal climate.
In Rhode Island, hardwood’s higher labor costs and humidity-sensitive nature can make LVP a more cost-effective solution for many homeowners. However, if your priority is resale value or you’re remodeling a luxury home, hardwood remains the gold standard for return on investment.
Climate Considerations for Rhode Island Homeowners
Rhode Island’s coastal environment adds a unique twist to the hardwood vs. LVP debate. The state’s humid summers, cold winters, and occasional nor’easters can challenge flooring materials.
LVP flooring is dimensionally stable and unaffected by moisture, making it ideal for lower levels, basements, or homes near the water. It also performs well in temperature shifts, staying quiet and comfortable year-round.
Hardwood floors need more care in these conditions. Using a humidifier in winter and maintaining stable indoor temperatures helps prevent gaps or warping. Engineered hardwood is slightly more resilient than solid hardwood, making it a viable choice if you love the authentic wood look but need better moisture control.
For professional help choosing the right flooring for your climate, learn more about our flooring store in North Kingstown.
Final Verdict: LVP or Hardwood?
Both LVP and hardwood offer unique strengths. However, choosing the most suitable product type for your home depends on your priorities.
Choose LVP if: You want stylish, waterproof floors that are budget-friendly and easy to maintain.
Choose hardwood if: You value natural beauty, tradition, and long-term property value.
We also looked at what the Reddit community has to say about choosing LVP vs. hardwood. Many users pointed out the hardwood’s durability and long lifespan.
Here’s a comment from one Redditor, who happens to be a professional flooring installer:
FAQ
Yes, luxury vinyl plank flooring is significantly cheaper both in material and installation costs. While hardwood can range from $8–$15 per square foot installed, LVP typically costs around $3–$7. This makes it an excellent option for homeowners seeking the hardwood look without the high price tag.
Hardwood flooring lasts much longer, often 50 years or more, with proper care. LVP usually lasts 15–25 years, depending on product quality. The key difference is maintenance: hardwood can be refinished multiple times, while LVP cannot.
Not necessarily. High-quality LVP with a realistic wood appearance can increase your home’s appeal, especially for buyers looking for low-maintenance floors. However, real hardwood is still considered the premium choice and typically adds more resale value overall.
Absolutely!
Today’s LVP flooring uses advanced printing and texturing technology to mimic the natural grain, knots, and tones of real hardwood. Many visitors won’t be able to tell the difference, especially when it’s professionally installed.
Looking for the most suitable flooring product?
Whether you’re leaning toward the durability of LVP or the timeless beauty of hardwood, the experts at Bart’s Carpet Sales can help you find the perfect match for your home.
With over 70 years of quality service, a 5-star rating from 305+ reviews on Google, and a team dedicated to professional installation and customer satisfaction, we’re Rhode Island’s trusted local flooring specialists.
We offer:
- Free in-home estimates and measurements
- Quality installation backed by a satisfaction guarantee
- Competitive pricing and personalized recommendations
- A wide selection of flooring products for every style and budget
- Extensive range of luxury vinyl flooring options
- Diverse hardwood flooring choices in our catalog
📍 Visit us at 491 Davisville Rd, North Kingstown, RI 02852
📞 Call (401) 884-8300 to schedule your free consultation today.
Whether you live in North Kingstown, Warwick, or nearby communities, our team is ready to help you upgrade your floors with confidence.